In many high-duty hoisting applications, electro-hydraulic disc brakes can provide performance advantages, especially related to heat management and torque consistency. Disc brakes often dissipate heat more efficiently than drum systems, which helps reduce brake fade risk during frequent stops or emergency braking scenarios. They also tend to offer stable braking characteristics across a wider temperature range when correctly specified.
That said, “better” still depends on the full system. High-duty hoisting requires not only rated torque, but also verified thermal capacity, correct friction material, predictable response time, and reliable fail-safe behavior. Electro-hydraulic disc brakes are commonly chosen when hoist speed is higher, stopping frequency is significant, or space constraints favor a disc layout.
To avoid premature wear or inconsistent holding, ensure correct installation alignment, proper disc thickness and surface condition, and a maintenance plan for pad wear and air gap control. For critical lifts, consider redundancy requirements and applicable crane standards.